★★★★★ 5.0 (72 reviews)
Short answer: the underlying community rates very well — but the marketing surrounding it oversells what any day-trading education can honestly promise. Separate the two before you decide.
Judged on what we can actually verify — a 5.0 rating across 72 reviews, 771 members, and a coach repeatedly described as a genuine mentor who members stick with for a full year — SPY Day Trading is a solidly-performing community, and the score reflects that. We're keeping it out of the very top tier for one reason worth separating from the community itself: the sales page's income claims ("$10,000 profits every day," "$1 million profits") are marketing, not a track record, and most written reviews are too brief to independently verify methodology. Neither of those is a knock on the mentorship members describe — they're just reasons to judge SPY Day Trading on its real numbers rather than its headline.
SPY Day Trading is built entirely around one instrument. If you'd rather go deep on SPY than spread across many tickers, that focus is the actual product here.
Multiple reviewers describe Eric as a genuine mentor, not just an alert feed — a good match if you want a relationship with a coach over time.
"$10,000 profits every day" is marketing copy, not a forecast. If you can mentally set that aside and evaluate the actual community and rating, there's a real, well-reviewed group underneath it.
If the six-figure account screenshots and "every day" language are the main reason you're considering this, pump the brakes — those are individual, self-reported, unaudited results, not typical outcomes.
Most written reviews here are very short. The rating is strong, but if you need detailed member accounts of specific results and methodology to feel confident, this review base won't fully satisfy that.
Day trading — including SPY day trading — is high-risk and fast-moving even with good mentorship. If you're not prepared for real capital risk, this style of trading may not fit regardless of the community quality.
Strip away the sales-page headlines and what's left is a 5.0-rated community with 771 members and reviews spanning purchases from a week old to a full year — that spread of purchase ages, still rating 5 stars, is a genuinely good retention signal. Multiple members single out Eric specifically for being accessible and invested in their progress, which is the kind of detail that's harder to manufacture than generic praise.
We want to be direct about this: "$10,000 PROFITS EVERY DAY" is not a realistic baseline expectation for day trading, at any skill level, with any mentor. The listing's carousel image citing "$1 million profits" alongside a large account screenshot is a single, self-reported, unaudited result being used as marketing — not evidence of what a typical member should expect. None of this means the community itself is bad; it means you should evaluate SPY Day Trading on its actual reviews and rating, and treat the headline income claims as sales copy to be filtered out, not a promise to hold them to.